A recent survey shows there to be 49% who are bullish and just 15% bearish.
That's the highest bullish rating since right before the crash of 1987, which occurred after a two-year, 150% stock market rally. Investors are more bullish today than they've been in over two decades.
That's the highest bullish rating since right before the crash of 1987, which occurred after a two-year, 150% stock market rally. Investors are more bullish today than they've been in over two decades.
Furthermore, the PE on the Wilshire 5000 is over 30 and the yield under 2%.
Now, on the one hand we shouldn't let pundets make a mokery of this. Don't let them make up excuses... "With a depressed economy we would have a lower earnings which inflates the multiple of the market."
They ALWAYS have excuses. What good is any indicator if you excuse it away? Why don't they just say, "That indicator is of no value!" Since they make up excuses every time, they are essentially saying just that.
Just delete the indicator altogether if you will make excuses. If an indicator has any water, it can not be excused away JUST BECAUSE you want to believe otherwise.
Most of these people are just greedy (or have a bias) and therefore will denigrate anything not in line with their hopes. That's NOT analysis.
Look, I have no lean on this issue. I show both sides. I'm just saying that I will just delete an indicator altogether if I will excuse away its readings. If the indicator is historically negative when it is at a given level, either I heed it or I delete it once and for all, never to use it again!
According to research by Yale University and the Wharton School Of Business, the P/E has major significance, historically. The projected return has HISTORICALLY been the inverse of the P/E. So, if the P/E is 15, that implies a 6.7% return going forward (1/15).
There is other research by Bogle (Vanguard), etc. supporting the notion that P/E is important.
It's NOT the only metric, but it is something to consider.
On the other hand, it can't be used to predict the market, but it does help one assess risk, historically speaking. In and of itself it should have no significance. Afterall, even two times earnings seems high. There is nothing INHERENT in it that would cause a problem. In addition, they say that at multiples of 15 and then the market sails higher to 17, 20, etc. So, there is nothing inherent in it that holds the market down.
And, at other times when it does top, is it coincidental? Are they using a small sample of observations? Is history prologue?
I mean the market is INEVITABLY going to top out. So eventually the P/E will be "right" but, it's always at a different number and only in hindsight do we know how high it will go this time before the market tops.
If you use it alone to time, you will be pretty early.
The issue is predominantly the self-fullfilling nature of it, i.e. once people get concerned (through looking at other issues), their negativity will lead them to look for other negatives. Then they will heed the multiple. I don't think the P/E is a driver like interest rates, emotions, dividends, etc., which have an inherent propensity to move the market.
Now, in conjunction with other things like rate of growth, speed of move, duration, I get concerned. But, never do I use P/E alone. If I did I would have sold in 1995 and missed the bull market. It does not matter that the market topped in early 2000 because I, gulp, sell. I believe buy and hold works for a few years during a bull. Then I sell.
The P/E pundets only show ONE SIDE of the story. It's important that they show BOTH sides. Sure, at bottoms the P/E has consistently been under 10. However, many times the P/E has been above the long term average of about 15 and yet the market continued going up for years.
The best course of action is to take some profits after huge run ups. Fixate on better metrics, drivers, with better track records than the P/E.
No comments:
Post a Comment