Sunday

Stock Market Returns.

If one likes money, they do not send it away.
 
Sure there will be good periods in the stock market, but even if you put it all in at the bottom, picked the right fund, didn't add a penny, then sold everything at the top, you'd still not be rich enough. You'd jack up spending. Jack up future idea of what you "need" to retire.
 
You'd ultimately forget the past return glory and another fix. You'd re-enter. As such, we want to consider OVERALL returns.
 
It's like the bank robber who never knows when to quit. He always returns and gets caught. Their ignorance. On the one hand it's bad because it's their ignorance that leads them to persue a life of crime. On the other hand, it is their ignorance that ultimately does them in, which is the redeeming benefit of that negative.
 
We take a median return of about 9.5%. The good thing is that it isn't the pessimist or optimist's opinion, it's in between, a 50/50, so it's a better estimate.
 
Note though, the median is very close to a probable best case of 12% (1:5 scenario, I consider). It's incredibly close when you consider the entire number system. It's about 2% away.
 
After taxes, inflation and costs, that premium slips further.
 
So, if I plug in 12%, pretty optimistic, rather than recent returns from the bottom, then strip out taxes (federal, state AND local capital gain, dividend and capital gain distributions), inflation and costs, and the absolute net return is hardly appetizing, hardly worth risking much for.

But, it doesn't end there, as wall street would have you believe. We do NOT compare to a "hole in the ground" (HITG, I designate it as). We compare to, say, a half the risk approach, which assumes as much luck and skill.
 
I continually look at the returns of various allocations. 20% equity vs. 60% equity. The difference is usually under 2% in average return. Not only that, the absolute gross return of 60% equity, in a very good scenario, compounded for 15 years (which is predicated on the idea that I am a very good investor meeting all the built in assumptions) is not much better!
 
Why would I take 3 times more equity risk for peanuts? And, that is at the GROSS level.
 
Even if it added up, it matters not because the lower risk approach in this optimistic scenario would be more than adequate. I can estimate my costs with a tiny standard deviation, significantly lower than the standard deviation of the stock market or anyone's prediction. Whatever can be said about the possiblity of a rainy day, fluke cost, can be said of the stock market even more so. What if I have a bad medical condition? Yet, what if the stock market doesn't realize that optimistic scenario (significantly more likley, in fact it's probable).
 
Besides, if I get sick and have a lot of my money in the stock market I will have to sell any old time, rather than use good analysis. My decision making would be poor if I am THAT sick. The talking heads forget to mention that OUR OWN BEHAVIOR has significant relevance, not just the market's behavior.
 
If I get sick when old, tons of money will be small consolation. In most cases, all the money in the world can only drag out an illness, not cure it.
 
Excess and status aren't much benefit if one is sick. Yet, if we strip out excess materialism and status, one finds that they need far less money when old.
 
Really, the only issue is the wild card of health. If we hold that aside for a moment, we will realize that our costs when old will be low.
 
In reality the lower the risk the better able we are to approximate the best case. The more likley the top 20% will repeat, so we go with those.
 
So, I note that betting 60% and getting 12% gross vs. 20% allocation, there is scant difference after 15 years. And, remember, this assumes a very optimistic scenario and a ton of built in assumptions are met perfectly.
 
Yawn.
 
After 15 years I'd be in the SAME BOAT. My lifestyle would be no better. At best, I'd have some excess dollars (MARGINAL UTILITY - definitely not worth jacking up risk for!).
 
So, why bother?
 
Instead, take lower risk and derive real time benefits. If there were none, we'd take high risk.
 
Why wish my time away? Only if I don't care about the reward would I not wish time away. If something is of value, I want it to arrive fast (i.e. wish time away).

If I am not going to wish time away it means it is not of value.
 
Only those who don't like money are willing to tie it up for decades, holding their breath. I don't treat things of value that way.
 
That would mean I assign no value to money, if I am willing to send it off for decades. Would I do that with something else of value?
 
Oh, but you could sell anytime? But that would ruin it all because anytime before and you don't end up with much better reward, i.e. NO reward, given the risk increase.
 
Besides, you sell and you have to come back in. You have to reinvest all profits. Were back to square one. Unless you have a crystal ball, you are going to be lucky to get 12%. So even if you sell it it can only be temporarily out of the market.
 
Keep in mind, that 12% is of a CHERRY PICKED index. Few people equal the index fund, let alone an index. They are showing us a SLIVER of the market, NOT a diversified portfolio. They are only showing the BEST, which is not possible to ID in advance. And, the thing that does very well is very apt to lag going forward. Supply & demand, regression to the mean, cycles, etc.
 
So, 12% is massively optimistic.
 
In addition, these market representatives are predicating on LUMP 100% of assets OR intended allocation IN/OUT investing style that few practice.

They assume 100% capture rate of the BEST representative of the market, known only in hindsight - yet shown in real time as if it was obvious or the only logical representative... and forever forward (a "final truth"). Yet, go ahead and buy that cherry picked representative that at the time everyone is saying is the only legitimate choice.
 
Then only after it has gone way down and for a long time will they finally stop recommending it. Is that a sell recommendation? If so, you are selling near the bottom. Yet, even if you hold, it will end up with mediocre or worse returns. YET, the game goes on. They will never bring it up and then repeat the bs yet again, recommending a new "final truth." And the beat goes on.
 
Of course, you don't listen to this stuff. But, it just goes to show that no one knows and we should bet accordingly.
 
Money is not just meant to be spent, it's meant to be enjoyed. There are many ways to enjoy money, beyond just spending it.
 
We should not extrapolate recent market returns too far into the future. Ultimately, they will slow down. Overall, returns will return to historic levels.
 
No matter how good the recent has been, it does not change the upper bounds. It does not change the inevitable range of returns. In general, the long term returns are pretty clustered. And, it's just a matter of how it transpires. For example, we have had a massive jump of late. But, if it had instead been slow moving, the end result would be the same, perhaps better.

No comments:

Post a Comment