According to Vanguard, who was addressing the question of why their funds don't go to cash: "Allocation decisions belong with the individual investor."
* You must decide the percent you want on stocks. When you give a mutual fund money you are saying, "Bet all this money on stocks and hold them. Do NOT go to cash (that is MY decision)."
The public has a very selective memory. At the top they were all wanting the fund to be fully invested. Then way down they act like they weren't thinking that at the top.
Oh, but it's not your job to ascertain tops, etc.? It sure is NOT the job of the mutual fund.
MOST mutual funds are long only, perma bull, fully invested.
The only exceptions you can easily spot: Income funds, balanced funds, asset allocation funds, long/short funds, hedge funds and a few others who history shows they will make big shifts (read the prospectus, look up a report on the fund on Morningstar, etc.).
Yet, income funds, balanced funds and most asset allocation fund make only MINOR changes vs. their target allocation.
Just don't expect them to go to cash.
* MF focus primarily on security selection and 2nd sector.
* MF make only small changes. They are tinkerers.
* MF are too big to dive in and out.
* Costs would be enormous. Returns are NOT unlimited yet we definitely have risk of huge loss.
* MF suffer from asset bloat.
* MF suffer from cash flows from hot money.
* Even if your mutual fund times, they will be wrong much of the time and you will complain that they are in cash when the market is up.
It's important to judge a manager based on his MANDATE and CONSTRAINTS NOT by whether a loss is good or not. No kidding. We all know up is better than down. That is not the issue. The issue is: Did the manager do average or better? Did he do his job?
Sure, we don't like to lose, but is the manager at fault? We have to compare vs. the benchmark for their mandate and constraints.
Imagine if you had to stay fully invested in stocks. Would you do better? If so, it's probably due to luck, asset bloat, and lack of shareholder hot money cash flows.
Just like the swimmer is not deemed slow simply because we can run faster than he swims. He is doing his job if he is doing average or better vs. OTHER SWIMMERS. We can't expect him to get out of the pool and sprint. That's not his job/mandate.
Be sure to look up a mutual fund's equity position. Unless you have specific information to the contrary, it's apt to stick to that percent (within 5-10%) REGARDLESS OF THE MARKET. You won't like that in a bear but then way up off the bottom when you finally turn bullish you will be glad they didn't listen to you.
Mutual funds are NOT timers, traders, asset class allocators or market analysts so do not judge them as such.
If you want to keep losses small, it is up to you.
If you don't think markets can fall, study history, etc. If you do know this, why assume it can't happen after you buy?
Of course, you have to accept that by betting less you have less potential. Of course, late bear no one cares about that! However, you will CHANGE YOUR MIND and be upset you missed out. That's INEVITABLE. You have to find a compromise.
Don't wait till the market is way down to think, "Gee, stocks can go down!" Duh! Think that late bull (and other times) and then decide then what percent you can bet where if you lose 80% of it, you won't be all furious... or at least not to the point where you lash out and sell huge.
I will make mistakes and I won't like it, but I accept it. Besides, in advance I did basic contingency planning for the scenario, to limit losses should I make a mistake or make no mistakes and yet things go wrong anyway (even a flawless swing in baseball is not guaranteed to lead to a base hit).
http://OnIncome.net
* You must decide the percent you want on stocks. When you give a mutual fund money you are saying, "Bet all this money on stocks and hold them. Do NOT go to cash (that is MY decision)."
The public has a very selective memory. At the top they were all wanting the fund to be fully invested. Then way down they act like they weren't thinking that at the top.
Oh, but it's not your job to ascertain tops, etc.? It sure is NOT the job of the mutual fund.
MOST mutual funds are long only, perma bull, fully invested.
The only exceptions you can easily spot: Income funds, balanced funds, asset allocation funds, long/short funds, hedge funds and a few others who history shows they will make big shifts (read the prospectus, look up a report on the fund on Morningstar, etc.).
Yet, income funds, balanced funds and most asset allocation fund make only MINOR changes vs. their target allocation.
Just don't expect them to go to cash.
* MF focus primarily on security selection and 2nd sector.
* MF make only small changes. They are tinkerers.
* MF are too big to dive in and out.
* Costs would be enormous. Returns are NOT unlimited yet we definitely have risk of huge loss.
* MF suffer from asset bloat.
* MF suffer from cash flows from hot money.
* Even if your mutual fund times, they will be wrong much of the time and you will complain that they are in cash when the market is up.
It's important to judge a manager based on his MANDATE and CONSTRAINTS NOT by whether a loss is good or not. No kidding. We all know up is better than down. That is not the issue. The issue is: Did the manager do average or better? Did he do his job?
Sure, we don't like to lose, but is the manager at fault? We have to compare vs. the benchmark for their mandate and constraints.
Imagine if you had to stay fully invested in stocks. Would you do better? If so, it's probably due to luck, asset bloat, and lack of shareholder hot money cash flows.
Just like the swimmer is not deemed slow simply because we can run faster than he swims. He is doing his job if he is doing average or better vs. OTHER SWIMMERS. We can't expect him to get out of the pool and sprint. That's not his job/mandate.
Be sure to look up a mutual fund's equity position. Unless you have specific information to the contrary, it's apt to stick to that percent (within 5-10%) REGARDLESS OF THE MARKET. You won't like that in a bear but then way up off the bottom when you finally turn bullish you will be glad they didn't listen to you.
Mutual funds are NOT timers, traders, asset class allocators or market analysts so do not judge them as such.
If you want to keep losses small, it is up to you.
If you don't think markets can fall, study history, etc. If you do know this, why assume it can't happen after you buy?
Of course, you have to accept that by betting less you have less potential. Of course, late bear no one cares about that! However, you will CHANGE YOUR MIND and be upset you missed out. That's INEVITABLE. You have to find a compromise.
Don't wait till the market is way down to think, "Gee, stocks can go down!" Duh! Think that late bull (and other times) and then decide then what percent you can bet where if you lose 80% of it, you won't be all furious... or at least not to the point where you lash out and sell huge.
I will make mistakes and I won't like it, but I accept it. Besides, in advance I did basic contingency planning for the scenario, to limit losses should I make a mistake or make no mistakes and yet things go wrong anyway (even a flawless swing in baseball is not guaranteed to lead to a base hit).
http://OnIncome.net
No comments:
Post a Comment