Sunday

Can Stocks Make Your Rich?

According to the Federal Reserve's Survey Of Consumer Finances, only 8% of the nation's richest (top 10%) got rich via stocks! Yikes! They must have had a big amount of money to invest, to begin with. They obviously had a high paying job, business, or inheritance (About 25% of the rich got some or all of their riches from inheritance).

Check out the "Millionaire Next Door". The author interviewed 1,000 millionaires. They did NOT get rich from stocks.

A few years ago I noted that just one person on the Forbes 400 got rich due to stocks, Warren Buffet. YET, he got rich by WORKING ON WALL STREET, running a business that provided a service. In addition, he used to take over and run the companies, which helped boost his stock returns.

Anecdotally, I know of not a single person who owes his riches to stocks. I do, however, know a few who got decimated in the stock market. Most that have dabbled in stocks have generated lackluster returns. Every single rich person I know of made their money from a high paying job or business. One or two got rich after years of average salary and saving every nickel. Trouble is, it took a long time and they really never had enough time to enjoy it. And, because it took so long, they were blaise about it.
Gradually achieving something makes the day of capture a ho hum day.

Perhaps the best way to ascertain if stocks will make you rich is to do the math. I mean we can't come out and say stocks won't make you rich because everyone has a different bet amount. And, some will get lucky. Assume a 9.5% median return. The median return since 1900 was 9.7%, the last time I checked. However, that is an INDEX, not an index fund. We need to deduct at least .2% in cost.

Given YOUR dollar bet, how long would it take for you to get rich on 9.5%?

But, wait!

Median is a good tool in general statistics. However, it is not nearly as reliable in the stock market.

And, median just tells us that 50% of the returns were higher than 9.5% and 50% were lower. So flip a coin, you have 50% shot of less than 9.5% returns. 9.5% is pretty mediocre - we are just programmed to believe it's good by people who 9.5% is probably good. I say MAKE UP YOUR OWN MIND about what constitutes a good return from high risk.

Now, the probable best case long term (20 years or longer) return is around 12%. Yes, we've had one or 2 periods a bit higher than that, but they owe it to a fluke period (a once a century period).

To properly estimate return I recommend looking at median CAPITAL GAIN (price appreciation) returns and then tacking on today's dividend (currently about 2%).There's no reason to expect capital gain returns will be higher because the dividend is lower. In fact, a low divided might lead to lower capital gains. However, for the sake of argument, we'll just assume it has no impact. There's no reason we would expect a higher capital gain rate of return. So we need to be careful with assuming historic total returns will prevail.

Besides...

You need to figure out the NET RETURN. Gross returns do not pay the GROCeries.

Deduct taxes (federal, state, and local). That's about 30% in total (Federal capital gain and dividend/capital gain distribution taxes run about 20% and state and local taxes average about 10%).

Then deduct projected inflation of about 3% (the average since 1926, however it has been about 4% since 1960).

Then deduct costs. That means ALL costs related to investing.

Yikes! It aint pretty.

But, wait, they are showing us a survivor to represent stocks... and a cherry picked survivor, at that. Who knows in advance what they will be using to represent stocks in 2020, 2030, etc. Who knew in 1926. They were recommending something else then (i.e. whatever was up the most in the cycle, especially if it skewed up the long term return). Just like in 1950, 1965, 1982, etc. etc. Who knew what to buy and hold? What were they recommending then? How did it pan out? We are no better at predicting the future today. Besides, any acquired knowledge cancels out as our competition has the same info. They want you to believe that we "now know". We have the "final truth". They always say that and then change their minds, way down.

They have never been able to predict the market or what portfolio to hold, so why should we trust them now?

Keep in mind. In 1999, 85% of the mutual funds lagged the S&P 500. That says that 85%, at least, have no clue what is the best portfolio to buy and hold. And, keep in mind, that says that most who bought/held lagged the market. But, they compare only the TOP representative of buy/hold vs. average timers. Of course, the rest can't predict either, they are beneficiaires of the law of numbers. Or, they are skilled but not psychic.

They are NOT showing you an average portfolio that existed at the start point. What if you had equally weighted everything in existence at that point? Or, gone with any other diversification strategy?

Beware of chasing the conventional wisdom of the moment "properly diversified" portfolio. They don't like to tell us how they arrived at their "magic" portfolio, but it always seems to be mega-overweight whatever is up the most of late. Yet, what is the track record of so doing? Funny. They bag on people for chasing tech in early 2000 yet here they are recommending you chase! This tells me that they were among those recommending tech in early 2000. Chasers don't change.

Past performance is no guarantee and that applies to the "properly diversified" portfolio they now showcase as "the best long term". Long term returns vary. Eventually this "long term winner" will become - at least temporarily - a mediocre long term performer. And, what do we do with those? We avoid them. So many will end up selling low when the long term for it is now mediocre and then chase the moment's best long term.

Today's favored long term "best" portfolio will likely go on to mediocre or less returns (due to supply and demand, exploitation, etc.).

And, before we fall for the published stock market return, remember: Most people lag the market return. Look at the percentage of mutual funds that lag the market. Look at timers. Look at hedge funds. Look at the return of the average investor. Look at the "capture rate" of the average investor in high risk funds.

So, take a percent or two out of the published long term return.

But, wait, then you need to compare the NET median return, NOT to a hole in the ground, but a OPTIMAL half risk approach.

Wall Street obviously prefers we think stocks are the holy path to riches. Just like the real estate sales person says real estate is the way to go. And, the commodity sales person pushes commodities. And, the Karate instructor says his style is best. And, the media uses product class marketing to make us think news chasing is wise.

Go with the facts, instead.

Besides, stocks basically only can make one rich due to compounding over time, a WHOLE LOT OF TIME. That is, unless they have a huge bet to begin with.

By the way, think of the subsequent amounts you accumulate via compounding as your bet/risk. Don't just consider contributions as risk! Gains are yours. You end up upping your bet as you age. Even if it's no more percentage of our net worth. But, what if we repeatedly take profits to avoid upping the percentage? The return from compounding would then be less than they suggest.

It gets ever harder to keep reinvesting all your profits as you have ever more dollars on the line, especially since you are aging. Those dollars are ever harder to recoup. The dollars are ever more significant. There's ever more purchasing power. You get ever closer to an amount where you can scale down the risk and cruise into "just enough" riches. The regret gets bigger if you don't sell in time.

Why be greedy? Excess doesn't make one happy, well off enough does.

I only take risk for near term reward. I want to have plenty of time to enjoy the reward.

I do not like TENTATIVE rewards. If I win, I want to have it booked, for good (or at least the bulk of it). Or, I only want to suffer minimial pullbacks. When I earn salary, I don't want to have the boss coming to me and requesting the salary back - I EARNED that reward. I put forth time and energy - which I can not get back.

Just as with salary, I earned my return. I put in the time. I put in the effort. But, unlike with salary, I took high risk for that reward.

I question whether you are rich if it takes so long to acquire it. When you have so little time to enjoy it. When you need excess money, the least. When you are at an age where all you need is "just enough to barely survive".

Let's face it. Medical costs are the big issue. But, contrary to Wall Street hype, not everyone is going to be in bad health and have high medical costs.

I prefer to put my time into exercising, eating right, sleeping, rather than studying Wall Street opinons and noise. This way my medical costs will likley be nill. And, I will generate better returns, to boot!

Notice the rich. Every last one of them strived to get rich as fast as possible. Some may say "He was patient waiting for the business to make a profit. He was willing to wait years." Oh, sure, because he was drawing salary in the mean time, and getting rich.

We are bsed that attempting to get rich as fast as possible means buying into scams. In fact, there are plenty of sound methods that get one richer, faster. Getting a high paying job, cutting costs, using risk management, running a business, marrying rich, etc. None of these are scam ideas.

The cliche, "It takes money to make money" is so true on Wall Street. Of course, they mean it takes A LOT of money to make Big Money, money few have to bet. I guess they didn't want to come outright and say, "It takes BIG money to get rich" and scare away so many customers.

No comments:

Post a Comment